Metro Philly Suburbs Logo

Why Jazz Chisholm could make sense for the Phillies

Should the Phillies look into former Yankee as an option?

Posted

The Philadelphia Phillies have a challenging offseason ahead of them.

With needs throughout the roster and an aging core, the Phillies face an important decision: continue adding veteran pieces in an effort to win a championship or begin incorporating younger talent that can help sustain their window of contention.

One player who could help accomplish both objectives is Jazz Chisholm Jr.

MLB.com's Mark Feinsand listed the Phillies as a potential landing spot for the second baseman and outfielder, highlighting his age, athleticism and defensive versatility.

“Though Chisholm primarily played second base during his two years with the Yankees, he has extensive experience in the outfield, an ongoing area of need for the Phillies. Chisholm would immediately make Philadelphia’s aging roster younger, inject some much-needed speed and provide versatility with his ability to play both second and third base. Since the start of 2024, Chisholm’s 11.8 fWAR is higher than any Phillies position player during that span.”

After declaring his goal of joining the exclusive 50/50 club at the start of the year, Chisholm fell short of those expectations. While he finished with 41 stolen bases, the fourth-most in MLB, it was a disappointing season for Chisholm. He hit just 19 home runs and saw his OPS drop to .711, the lowest mark of his career outside of his 21-game rookie season in 2020. 

His 98 wRC+ was also his lowest since 2021, indicating that his offensive production fell below league average. He struck out a career-high 157 times. 

Despite the down year, there are reasons to believe Chisholm could bounce back. 

He is just one season removed from a 30/30 campaign in which he posted an .813 OPS, hitting 31 home runs and stealing 31 bases in his first full season with New York, earning his second All-Star selection and winning his first Silver Slugger award.

The Phillies haven't had a hitter not named Kyle Schwarber hit 30 homers in a season since Rhys Hoskins in 2022. Philadelphia hasn't seen a  30/30 season since Jimmy Rollins' MVP campaign in 2007. 

According to Jon Heyman, 11 teams have reportedly expressed interest in Chisholm.

Despite his struggles at the plate, his defensive versatility and the absence of a qualifying offer could make him an attractive option for multiple clubs.

Chisholm spent last season as the Yankees' everyday second baseman but has also seen time at third base and in center field.

In his seven-year career, he has appeared in 192 games in the outfield, although he hasn't played there since 2024 with Miami. That season, he made 95 starts primarily as the Marlins' center fielder.

That versatility could be particularly valuable for the Phillies.

With top prospect Aidan Miller potentially needing additional development time before taking over at third base, Chisholm could provide an option at the position, or he could man second base with Bryson Stott sliding to the hot corner. Chisholm's outfield experience would also give Philadelphia another avenue to address its needs in that department.

There are some drawbacks, however. 

Chisholm is a left-handed hitter, meaning he wouldn't address the Phillies' need for another right-handed bat. His inconsistent offensive production also presents some risk, particularly if the team is required to make a significant financial commitment.

Some of Chisholm's contract projections range anywhere from $40 million for a two-year deal to upwards of $70 million across three years, according to  Bleacher Report. 

Still, the combination of age, athleticism, power and speed makes Chisholm an intriguing potential addition.

For a Phillies team trying to remain in championship contention while also looking at getting younger, Chisholm could be the type of player Dave Dombrowski and the Phillies are looking at to maintain this championship window for as long as possible. 

Phillies, Jazz Chisholm Jr., MLB, Free Agency